Design Criteria

A set of necessary and sufficient design criteria to solve the complex global problems that we face today

Inspired by Ken Wilbur’s Integral Theory, the think tank called The Emergence Project created the above model.

The four quadrants represent these four metastructures: 

  • Memetic Structure (I = individual subjective): Human Values, Beliefs, Meaning, Orienting Stories and Narratives, Worldview, Identity, Definition of success
  • Physiologic Structure (IT = individual objective): Behavioral Influencers — Nutrition, Neurochemistry / Neurobiology, Endocrinology, Epigenetics, Toxicity, Nutrition
  • Social Structure (WE = collective intersubjective):  Economics, Governance, Law
  • Infrastructure (ITS = collective interobjective): Modes of production: Energy, Agriculture, Transportation, Energy Generation, Water, Building Technology, Waste Management

All factors that condition human behavior live in these quadrants. Each of the quadrants is fundamental and irreducible with respect to the others, so these categories are both necessary and sufficient for inventorying all sources of human conditioning.  

The metastructures co-evolve and co-influence each other in complex ways, and must all be factored together to effectively evolve society. Most social philosophies have emphasized one of these areas as fundamental, leading to projects focused in that area to the exclusion of the others. Such a reductionist orientation is simply inadequate for systems as complex and interconnected as human society and the biosphere.

Below are examples of metastructure shifts, by category. Note that these do not include all design criteria.

Memetic Structure

FromTo
Separate PartsInterconnected Wholes
False DichotomiesMeaningfully Reconciled Paradox
CompetitionCollaboration
Random UniverseEmergent Universe
Unifying Through HomogenyUnifying Across Diversity
Self-centered or Self-sacrificingOmni-considerate

Social Structure - Economics

FromTo
Win-lose structuresWin-Win structures
GrowthPost Growth & Evolving Homeostasis
Separate OwnershipResource Optimizing Commonwealth
Transactional AccountingSystemic Accounting
PossessionAccess
Extrinsic MotiveIntrinsic Motive
Competition as DriverConscious Evolution as Attractor
Profit / Resource ExtractionResource Circulation
Extraction & Production Cost AccountingLife Cycle Cost Accounting
Scarcity ValuationUtility Valuation
Competing MetricsComensurated Metrics

Social Structure - Governance

FromTo
Imposed (Command & Control)Emergent (Self-Governance)
Person MediatedProcess Mediated
Conflicting ValuesInclusive Holarchy of Values
Imperialistic vs. AnarchisticConsciously Self-regulating
Implicit OutcomesExplicit Outcomes
SymptomaticCause
Uncoordinated Partial SolutionsSystems Solutions
Opinion BasedData Based
Arbitrary PurviewGovernance at the Level of Effect Law
PunitiveProtective & Rehabilitating
InterventionaryPreventative

Infrastructure

FromTo
CentralizedDecentralized & Distributed
Linear Materials EconomyClosed Loop Materials Economy
Depleting & ExtractionaryRegenerative
FixedModular & Adaptive
GoodsServices
Possession & OwnershipAccess & Sharing Structures
Nature & Technology DivideBiomimicry
Commodity BasedTechnology Based
Labor Work ForceAutomation

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Stay in the loop with exclusive updates – Subscribe to our newsletter today!